At first glance, Half Magic looks another ‘girls – uh, middle-aged women – gone wild’ comedy in the vein of Bridesmaids and the litany of films that followed. Starring Heather Graham – best known for her kooky, comedic roles – and TV sitcom stars Stephanie Beatriz (of Brooklyn Nine-Nine) and Angela Kinsey (of the American Office), you’re conditioned to expect misadventures and splashes of gross-out comedy, as has become the norm in female-starring comedies over the last decade.
While Half Magic isn’t a world away from those films, it’s not another Bad Moms or Girls Trip. Written and directed by Graham, the film avoids familiar clichés for a more thoughtful examination of workplace inequality and women’s insecurities. When the three woman form an impromptu friendship at a “Love Your Pussy” self-help seminar (hosted by Molly Shannon), they set out to help each other tackle their life problems – most of which revolve around sex. Graham’s unhappily dating her obnoxious boss, a misogynistic movie star (Chris D’Elia); Beatriz’s layabout boyfriend wants an open relationship; and Kinsey, while contending with her ex-husband’s (Thomas Lennon’s) advances, struggles to see herself as sexy anymore.
Unlike the majority of post-Bridesmaids comedies written and directed by men, Half Magic has a distinctly female perspective. Its depiction of workplace sexual harassment and Hollywood sexism is exaggerated enough to be funny – though D’Elia’s in a whole different gear to everyone else in the movie – but is clearly drawn from a place of real hurt (Graham was one of the earliest to speak up in the wave of Weinstein accusations). The film is sexy, but without objectification; the single nude scene is less about the body than the character’s confidence in her own body. In an industry dominated by bro-comedies – even the one starring women – this feels gently revolutionary, refreshingly real.
There’s a lot to like about Half Magic. The three leads – playing variations on Graham’s wide-eyed naïf schtick – all do great work, levelling out the comedic elements with an aura of authenticity. Beatriz plays an entirely different role to her work on Brooklyn Nine-Nine – she’s an eternal optimist, bouncy and cheerful throughout – while Kinsey elevates her role by subtly emphasising a quivering sadness.
Ultimately, however, the film is just ‘okay’. The writing needed to be sharper – better jokes, or at least a more consistent tone – the pacing cleaner, the camerawork less mid-budget TV sitcom. But if I’m being honest, I’d much prefer a string of ‘okay’ comedies like this than the formulaic, improvisation-heavy schlock that’s come to dominate studio output in recent years. Half Magic could’ve been a lot better, but it has something that most of its competitors lack: a point of view.
I just heard Graham on the WTF Podcast, and she definitely made me interested to check this out. I’m glad to hear it’s okay, and I’m happy for Graham that she got the chance to make it.
Oh, it’s definitely more interesting as a passion project – a sort of expulsion of years of working in this industry as an easily-dismissed sex symbol – than a film in its own right. But it’s not bad either way!
(Also, sorry for the late reply – my notifications have been screwy lately. Thanks for the comment!)