It’s astounding how effortless Richard Linklater’s Before Sunrise and Before Sunset feel. Each captures a miraculous authenticity that could be derailed by a moment of artifice: a clunky line of dialogue here, an unconvincing line-reading there, even a showy shot that draws attention to itself could scuttle the film’s immersive realism, the unbroken illusion that we’re watching people, not actors.
Following Jesse (Ethan Hawke) and Celine (Julie Delpy) over one day (Sunset) or night (Sunrise), the films capture the fragility of time, its syrupy slowness. Knowing they have only hours together, Jesse and Celine’s every conversation is redolent with meaning, every phrase and gesture important. They are swimming upstream in the river of time, fighting the current, every stroke taking an eternity while, paradoxically, time trickles inexorably away.
With such time constraints and without the scaffolding of a traditional narrative, every conversation invites analysis and, thankfully, rewards it. The dialogue is reminiscent of Tarantino at his best; instead of the simmering tension or foreshadowed violence that animates QT’s dialogue (where characters discuss everything except the purpose of the scene), the Before films are underpinned by the intense connection between these two individuals. Their bond is immediate and intense from their first encounter.
Before Sunrise finds them dancing around this bond, alternating between self-conscious posturing and jolts of revealing honesty. Watching at around the characters’ age, I found their conversations romantic; rewatching recently I could still appreciate the romance, but was aware of the way Celine and especially Jesse spent so much energy putting up a façade, enrobing themselves in a carefully-constructed persona, the “optimal” version of themselves. In their early twenties, the characters are trying to become who they believe they ought to be. By Before Sunset, they’re more comfortable, settled in their own skin. They’re more guarded; the majority of the sequel is spent with the two engaging in careful verbal probing and feinting: note how long it is before either asks the other about marriage, or children. Age has brought confidence in themselves, but eroded their instinctive trust of each other, at least until that profound connect re-asserts itself.
I write this shortly before watching the series’ third instalment, Before Midnight. If the critical buzz is to be believed, I’m expecting it to match or eclipse the quality of its predecessors. But more than anything, I’m looking forward to spending a little more time with Jesse and Celine.
6 thoughts on “Double Feature: Before Sunrise (1995) and Before Sunset (2004)”
Nice review mate. Great movies, aren’t they? Loved them both and I find it really difficult to separate them. I think I prefer Sunrise slightly more but only just. Looking forward to your review of Midnight, it’s one of my favourite films of the year. It’s a little different but I think it works brilliantly.
Thanks! I’ve seen Sunrise twice and Sunset once, so I think I’d need another viewing of the latter before I pick – they’re very hard to separate. Will likely have my Before Midnight review up tomorrow, still sorting my thoughts out!
And I hope you are as pleased as I, and so many I have discussed “Before Midnight” with are. Seven months in…it’s still the best film of 2013. ML
It was very good! Certainly a big departure from the earlier films in terms of tone, though not the spirit behind it. I have some thoughts but I’ll probably wait ’til tomorrow for a review. I don’t think it beats Spring Breakers for my favourite film of the year thus far, but I need more time for it to marinate.
Pingback: Extended Cut: Before Midnight (2013) | ccpopculture
Pingback: Slacker (1991) | ccpopculture